Nefertiti Back Home

Nefertiti's Departure Plot

For more than a century Nefertiti’s bust has been suffering from loneliness in Europe. Since 1920 Egypt, and Germany have been fighting each other about owning the bust, because it is a very unique masterpiece. It was made of limestone, coloured plaster, and wore a conical headdress[185]. All these aspects made the bust a unique masterpiece, it was discovered in 1912 by Ludwig Borchardt in Tell el-Amarna in a workshop which belongs to Thutmose who was the court sculptor[186]. The bust went to James Simon who was the sponsor of the mission, led by the German oriental society[187]. This society was founded in 1898 to hold studies of antiquity in the near, and Middle East. Borchardt did his best to make sure that the bust would be from the German side. According to the partage law, and regulations at that time, all recurring and common artefacts of any discovery would be divided between the Egyptian Antiquities Authority and the foreign mission concerned, while the unique, and distinctive artefacts must be placed in the Egyptian share[188]. Wafaa El-Seddiq is the head of the International Union for the Preservation of heritage, and the former director of the Egyptian museum said that according to documentation, and the diary of Borchardt deduced that he knew that the bust belonged to Nefertiti from the first day of discovery. He described the statue as gypsum, not limestone, also the name was mentioned as (an unknown royal family princess). The fact is he knew the true identity so he falsified the description to prove that The statue is a normal one, and it is not important so the bust went to the German share[189].

Figure 18: James Simon, the owner of Nefertiti’s bust, g​ave his collection to the Berlin Museum including Nefertiti (mattia mancini 2014).

Figure 19: Entry by Ludwig Borchardt in his excavation diary 1912–1913 on finding the Nefertiti bust (Ägyptisches Museum und Papyrussammlung 2012, page 43).

Figure 20: Prince Johann Georg of Saxony, presentation of the Nefertiti Bust at the find site, 1912, left to right: excavation supervisors Herrmann Ranke, Paul Hollander, Mohammed es-Senussi (Ägyptisches Museum und Papyrussammlung 2012, page 44)

Until 1924 the bust was hidden, its first appearance was in the Egyptian Museum in Berlin. The Egyptian government was very surprised to see the statue and began to threaten the German excavation to ban them from doing excavation in Egypt until the restitution of the bust, but the German did not care about this threat. In 1929 other artifacts were placed to be exchanged with the bust by the Egyptian government, but German declined,[190] These artifacts are two Statues of (Ra Nefer), and Amenhotep Ibn Habu[191]. Another attempt to restitute the bust by the Egyptian government was done and in the beginning, Adolf Hitler who was the Nazis leader did not mind to return the bust, but after he saw it he had fallen in love with the bust and refused the restitution. Eberhard von Stürer, the German ambassador in Egypt had been told by Hitler a message to send to the Egyptian government “I am one of the big fans of the queen Nefertiti, she brings me joy to my heart, the bust is a masterpiece and a unique treasure. I am planning to build a new Egyptian museum in Berlin. I am dreaming of this. I will build inside a room surmounted by a great dome, and the magnificent Nefertiti will sit a crowned queen in the middle of it, and I will never give up the queen's head”[192].

“The lovely woman is no more”
After the end of WWII in 1970 specially in Berlin, something disastrous happened, Steffen Wenig, the curator on the duty on the museum island ordered his colleagues to come back to work during their vacation for an urgent meeting. He started his talk saying “Nefertiti the lovely woman, is no more, a visitor child knocked over the statue, and fell on the floor causing it to shatter. The statue mentioned belongs to Nefertiti that was found on November 26,1912 by the Egyptologist Hermann Ranke. The statue was as fragments on the floor between room 19, and 18 in the so-called house of the sculptor Thutmose. The statue was broken in ancient times, they collected the fragments, and reconstructed it in the Berlin museum. The statue is made of limestone as the bust of Nefertiti. After around 57 years the statue was broken in the Berlin museum under the authority of the museum curator, and German authority. The head was broken into seven parts, the neck was broken into four pieces, and the rest of the body was shattered into many pieces. After the accident of the statue Uta von Eickstedt is the restorer who worked on it, his restoration for the statue was not correct according to Venice charter 1964 (before the accident 1970 happened). The restorer used metal splint instead of limestone to reconstruct the statue, also he did not reconstruct the right hand which its reconstruction was possible due to plaster replicas. All these restoration works according to Venice charter 1964 article No 9 which states that “The process of restoration is a highly specialized operation. Its aim is to preserve and reveal the aesthetic and historic value of the monument and is based on respect for original material and authentic documents. It must stop at the point where conjecture begins, and in this case moreover any extra work which is indispensable must be distinct from the architectural composition and must bear a contemporary stamp. The restoration in any case must be preceded and followed by an archaeological and historical study of the monument” [193]. According to all the accidents, and series mentioned above the antiquities suffer from smuggling by the west, do not have a proper preservation standard, nor will they get proper conservation works as Nefertiti’s statue had.  

Antiquities during WWII 

In the first half of the 20th century the interest in Egyptology in Europe had reached its peak, this also generated the desire to acquire other types of antiquities. The Europeans started to challenge each other to collect magnificent antiquities as national collections for their countries, and private ones as Sir John Soane private collection 8. In 1939 World War II started, led by Adolf Hitler whose dream was to control the world and to collect all the antiquities in Europe. It was clearly a turbulent period; Due to the widespread plundering and the nations' desire to protect their national treasures steps were taken to secure and move their most precious artifacts. His project was titled Hitler's Dream, it was to construct a huge museum in the Austrian city of Linz, many works of art were collected for the project. By the end of the war, there were Nazis speculating about the secret locations where many works would be concealed, and in the event of real defeat, Hitler ordered them to destroy every piece they had. 

During 1943, the works of art had been transferred to different mines in Altaussee, Merkers, and a copper mine at Siegen. Michelangelo’s Madonna (Virgin Mary) of Bruges that was stolen from the church of Virgin Mary, and Jan van Eyck’s Ghent Altarpiece stolen from Saint Bavo Cathedral were hidden in the Altaussee mine. Lately, many rumors suggest that it is in a Swiss bank vault[194].

Precious artifacts lost in World War II 

Raphael, portrait of a young man. This painting belongs to Poland; it was the most famous lost artwork from Poland during the WWII. It was taken from the Czartoryski family collection to be delivered to Hilter’s Führer museum in 1939. Unfortunately, at the end of WWII the painting was not found, it may have been destroyed as Hitler’s ordered his men at the end of war to destroy all the artifacts in case of losing, or maybe it was just stolen and hidden[195].

Raphael, portrait of a young man. This painting belongs to Poland; it was the most famous lost artwork from Poland during the WWII. It was taken from the Czartoryski family collection to be delivered to Hilter’s Führer museum in 1939. Unfortunately, at the end of WWII the painting was not found, it may have been destroyed as Hitler’s ordered his men at the end of war to destroy all the artifacts in case of losing, or maybe it was just stolen and hidden[195].

Figure 21: Altaussee salt Mine where was a mine for storing the arts smuggled by Hitler’s army (Altaussee Salt Mines, 2022)

Figure 22: This is a portrait of a young man by Raphael (STAŃSKA, 10) paragraph 3

Figure 23: Open view; when opened the altarpiece measures 11ft x 15ft (3.5m x 4.6m). Jan van Eyck (circa 1390–1441) (Graham, 2022).

Figure 24: Copy of the Just Judges. Jan van Eyck (circa 1390–1441) (Graham, 2022). 

References